The Greatest Movie Villains: Ranking Their Chances of Survival in the Real World
We’re used to seeing “the good guy” always win in almost every movie. It’s the Hollywood template for a satisfying ending, and studies show that it’s what most people prefer to see—but in real life, most of the good guys wouldn’t stand a chance.
So, what if we took some of the greatest villains and applied their logic, motivations, and skills to the real world? The consequences would be catastrophic. After all, these characters are driven by selfish and destructive motives, and their victories would likely lead to widespread suffering and chaos.
For example, if the Joker, the iconic Batman villain, were to win in the end, Gotham City would likely descend into anarchy. The Joker is a chaotic and unpredictable force, and his victory would likely result in widespread destruction and the loss of life across the globe.
Similarly, if the Terminator, the cyborg assassin from the eponymous movie series, were to win in the end, it could spell disaster for humanity. The Terminator is a ruthless killing machine, and its victory would lead to the end of mankind altogether.
If Sauron, the dark lord from The Lord of the Rings series, were to win in the end, Middle-earth would be plunged into an age of darkness and despair. Sauron is a malevolent and powerful being, and his victory would spell doom for all of the free peoples of Middle-earth.
So who are some of the greatest villains we’ve seen in movies who definitely would win in real life (outside of their predetermined storylines to lose in the end)? What would the end result look like?
John Doe in “Seven“
John Doe, the main antagonist of the 1995 crime thriller film Seven, is a powerful villain and your worst nightmare.
First off, Doe is a formidable and dangerous foe due to his high intelligence and education. He can outwit and outmaneuver the police, making him challenging to apprehend.
Doe is motivated by a sick and sadistic ideology, and he is prepared to carry out gruesome and horrific murders in order to prove his point. His ruthlessness and terrifying nature result from this.
He is able to remain calm and composed even in the face of extreme danger, adding to his sense of menace.
With his bald head and distinctive glasses, John Doe has an instantly recognizable appearance that has added to his enduring popularity and solidified his status as a formidable movie villain. Let’s not forget that in the movie, he was only caught because he wanted to be caught.
Finally, the actor who portrays Doe, Kevin Spacey, gives a memorable and chilling performance that adds depth and complexity to the character.
The Gremlins in “Gremlins“
The Gremlins, the main antagonists of the 1984 horror comedy film Gremlins, are terrifying just based on their looks alone.
First off, the gremlins are small and agile, making them difficult to catch and kill. This adds to their sense of danger and makes them formidable enemies.
They are intelligent and cunning, able to manipulate their surroundings and outsmart their opponents. This makes them more than just mindless monsters and adds to their threat level.
The gremlins are also able to multiply and reproduce quickly, making them more difficult to eliminate. This adds to the sense of chaos and devastation that they cause.
Their ability to transform into more powerful and aggressive forms makes them even more dangerous and adds to their threat level.
Finally, the Gremlins’ iconic appearance, with their mischievous expressions and distinctive appearance, has contributed to their lasting popularity and helped to cement their place as powerful movie villains.
Anne Wilkes in “Misery“
Annie Wilkes, the antagonist of the 1990 psychological thriller Misery, is the worst kind of psychopath. She goes from hot to cold and back to hot again before you can even think about your next move.
First and foremost, Wilkes is an expert at manipulation and control. She can appear to her victim as a kind and caring nurse while secretly harboring violent and disturbed thoughts. Because of her duality, she is unpredictable and creepy.
Second, Wilkes is motivated by an unhealthy fixation with the main character, a bestselling novelist whom she saves after a car accident. As the film unfolds, this preoccupation becomes increasingly out of control, leading to violent and horrific behaviors.
Third, Wilkes is extremely sadistic and enjoys causing pain and suffering to others. This makes her a truly frightening and dangerous character. Wilkes is a classic example of the narcissist-sociopath combination
Fourth, Wilkes’ iconic appearance, with her frumpy clothing and distinctive southern accent, has contributed to her lasting popularity and helped to cement her place as a classic movie villain.
Keyser Söze in “The Usual Suspects“
Keyser Söze is the main antagonist of the 1995 crime film The Usual Suspects. He is a terrifying villain for several reasons.
First, Söze is a master of manipulation and deception. He is able to manipulate events and people to achieve his own ends and is extremely skilled at covering his tracks. This makes him a formidable and unpredictable enemy. For starters, Keyser Söze is an enigma: he’s damn near omnipresent, nobody knows his true identity or motivations, and the clues to unlocking his secret are few and far between.
Third, Söze is extremely violent and ruthless, willing to go to great lengths to protect his interests and eliminate anyone who stands in his way. This makes him a fearsome and dangerous opponent. It’s also what makes him seem like the bogeyman for gangsters.
Fourth, Söze’s iconic appearance, with his scarred face and distinctive European accent, has contributed to his lasting popularity and helped to cement his place as a classic movie villain.
The combination of his extreme violence, his determined will to protect what is his, and the mysterious persona that comes with it make him the perfect embodiment of a movie villain who most likely would never lose in real life, because… how do you arrest or kill someone who doesn’t exist?
The Joker in “The Dark Knight“
The Joker is a strong villain and is widely debated as one of the best of all time.
The Joker is a master of manipulation and deception, using his intelligence and wit to outmaneuver his opponents. This makes him a formidable and dangerous enemy in every way possible. To make matters worse, he is an anarchist with no set agenda, making him unpredictable and more dangerous than the average bad guy.
He is also a master of psychological warfare, using fear and intimidation to break his enemies down before they can even begin to fight back. The Joker has a unique and powerful ability to control the people and situations around him, making him one of the most difficult villains to defeat.
How long do we think Batman could hold the Joker off in real life without killing him? At some point the Joker would set his sights outside of Gotham and target the country…or the world. Then what?
Finally, the Joker’s iconic appearance, with his distinctive purple suit and white makeup, has contributed to his lasting popularity and helped to cement his place as a strong movie villain.
Why Do Villains Matter So Much?
Everybody loves a great “bad guy.”
Villains are important in a movie because they provide the conflict and obstacles that the protagonist must overcome. Without a villain, there is no conflict, and the movie becomes less interesting and less engaging for the viewer.
They often represent the darker aspects of humanity and serve as a way for the audience to explore and confront their own fears, doubts, and moral dilemmas. A well-written villain can make a movie more thought-provoking and memorable, as they help to create a sense of tension and drama.
Villains can be used to comment on societal issues or to hold a mirror up to the audience, challenging their assumptions and beliefs. In this way, villains can be a powerful tool for storytelling and can help to make a movie more meaningful and impactful.
If you liked this, then make sure to check out the blog post on what makes an unforgettable villain. You’ll notice they have a lot more in common than you think.
Digital Screenwriting Course
Creating the Ultimate Protagonist
Characters are story. Your protagonist is your most important character. In this course you will learn how to create the best of both.View Online CourseView Online Course
Character, Plot & Theme
Learn how to create a protagonist the audience can identify or empathize with.
Learn from popular movie examples, video lectures, downloads and articles.